When new self-storage opens near you, your income usually falls first and your value falls faster. Owners who understand why can act early. Owners who wait often sell after the damage is done.
This post covers how overbuilding happens, what it does to the numbers on one example facility, and what to do about it.
How Overbuilding Happens
Overbuilding is the sum of reasonable decisions. Each developer sees steady occupancy and population growth and builds. None counts how many other developers see the same thing.
Projects take a year or more from financing to opening. A market that looked undersupplied at financing can be oversupplied at the ribbon cutting. Once a project is financed, nothing stops it.
Five buildings aimed at the same demand do not produce five winners. The first to fill does best. The rest compete on price.
Watch for these four signs:
- Slow lease-up. New facilities take much longer than planned to fill. Demand may be thinner than the builders assumed.
- Specials appear. Free months and move-in discounts mean operators can't get full rent. Once specials start, they are hard to pull back. Vacancies plus dropping prices signal oversupply.
- Street rate versus in-place rate. The street rate is what new customers are quoted. The in-place rate is what existing tenants pay. A gap is normal. Worry when street rates fall to or below what existing tenants pay.
- Rent increases stop sticking. When tenants push back or leave after an increase, or you stop sending them, in-place rates fall behind and income stalls.
Arizona, Nevada, and Utah: Check Your Own Market
Supply is local. Customers choose facilities close to home or work. In our experience, the market for most facilities is about a three- to five-mile radius. A growing metro can have a wave of new facilities while a town an hour away has none.
Owners in fast-growing areas and the corridors around them are the most exposed. Any size market can be overbuilt, and in a small town one new facility can be enough.
Three quick tests:
- Count the facilities under construction or approved within a few miles of yours. City and county planning offices can tell you what is coming.
- Shop the nearest competitors as a customer and ask for a 10x10. Compare to your street rate. A 10x10 benchmark is about $100 a month, or $1.00 per sf. Secondary markets in Arizona and Nevada run about $0.70 to $0.80 per sf. Utah runs about $0.65 per sf, and as low as $0.45 in very small markets.
- Compare your occupancy and move-ins for the last 12 months with the same months a year earlier.
What It Does to Your Numbers
Example: a small Arizona town (a secondary market) with a 33,000 net rentable sf facility, about 300 units. Market rent is $0.80 per sf per month. NOI margin is 55%, after a 6% management fee. Owner-run numbers often leave out the owner's pay, so the fee keeps the example honest.
Potential rent is what the facility would collect if every sf rented at the market rate. Economic occupancy is rent collected as a share of potential rent.
Base case:
- Potential rent: 33,000 x 12 x $0.80 = $316,800.
- Gross income at 90% economic occupancy: $316,800 x 0.90 = $285,120 per year.
- Expenses: $285,120 x 45% = $128,304. NOI (net operating income, what is left after operating costs): $156,816.
Now new supply arrives. Competition pushes the market rate to $0.76 per sf, so potential rent falls too. Economic occupancy slips to 85%.
- Potential rent: 33,000 x 12 x $0.76 = $300,960.
- Gross income: $300,960 x 0.85 = $255,816. That is a 10.3% drop.
- Expenses barely move. Payroll, insurance, utilities, and taxes don't fall with occupancy. Hold them at the base-case $128,304.
- NOI: $255,816 - $128,304 = $127,512. That is an 18.7% drop.
A 10% drop in revenue became a nearly 19% drop in NOI. The same pattern holds at any size.
Why Value Falls Faster Than Income
A cap rate is NOI divided by price, so price = NOI / cap rate. At a 7.0% cap rate, a buyer pays about 14.3 times NOI. At 8.0%, about 12.5 times. Buyers use cap rate as a shortcut, but they price on the income they expect to earn.
Value falls from two directions at once. This example uses 7.0% as the base, with 7.5% and 8.0% as weak-market assumptions. They are for illustration, not predictions.
- Base case: $156,816 / 0.07 = $2,240,229.
- Lower NOI only: $127,512 / 0.07 = $1,821,600.
- Lower NOI and a 7.5% cap rate: $127,512 / 0.075 = $1,700,160. That is a 24% drop in value.
- Lower NOI and an 8.0% stress case: $127,512 / 0.08 = $1,593,900. That is a 29% drop in value.
A 10% drop in revenue cost 24% to 29% of value here. Buyers worried about a weak market pay fewer dollars per dollar of income.
Lenders also size loans from NOI. Lower NOI means a smaller loan at refinance and a thinner cushion on the loan you have.
What Smart Owners Do Now
In an oversupplied market, the goal is to hold tenants and protect income.
- Run a clean, easy facility. Clean, secure, easy to rent, fast to answer the phone. When rents stop rising, tenants stay with the facility that treats them well.
- Hold your street rates. Say economic occupancy is 88% at $0.80 per sf. That earns 33,000 x 12 x $0.80 x 0.88 = $278,784. Cutting to $0.72 to reach 92% earns 33,000 x 12 x $0.72 x 0.92 = $262,310. You earn $16,474 less and fill more units. Cutting rate to chase occupancy often loses money.
- Check before every increase on existing tenants. Our usual practice is about 7% every 9 months. In an oversupplied market, compare your in-place rate with local street rates before each increase. Slow or skip the increase for tenants whose in-place rate is already at or above street. Those are the tenants who leave when competitors run specials.
- Know which unit sizes rent fastest. Put your sales effort where demand is strongest.
- Review your debt and your exit. Test whether you could still make loan payments if revenue fell 10 to 20 percent. If your loan comes due in the next few years, find out now what a lender will offer on today's NOI, not last year's.
- Consider a 1031 exchange. An exchange can defer capital gains tax when you sell and buy another property. Rules are strict, so talk to your tax advisor first.
A Broker's View
Buyers pay for income they can verify. They look at trailing 12-month results and at new supply nearby, because the supply pipeline shows how safe your income is. In our sales work, buyers ask about nearby supply early. A seller whose numbers are still strong gets more options than one whose numbers have already slipped.
That is the cost of waiting. If you sell after the drop, the buyer prices in the new supply and the slip.
Questions to Ask About Your Facility
- Is my market oversupplied? Compare your occupancy and rates with nearby facilities.
- How does my facility compare with the new ones nearby?
- What happens to my NOI if rates are flat and economic occupancy is 5 points lower? Run the math above on your own numbers.
- Would my capital earn more somewhere else?
The owners who do well see it early and decide, rather than hope.
Let's Look at Your Facilities
The Gorden Group works with self-storage owners across Arizona, Nevada, and Utah. We can show you where your property stands, and whether to hold, improve, or sell.
Connect with the Gorden Group