Latest News & Updates

October 22, 2026
 / 
Blog

Short answer: A tenant who stays and gets regular rate increases usually produces more cash than turning the unit over.

Some owners chase turnover: replace a tenant at a higher street rate and income goes up. That leaves out vacancy and turnover costs.

Leases run month to month, so any tenant can leave. "the longer a tenant stays, the more they are worth" (Osborne, Investors Guide).

Our rate practice

We generally raise existing-tenant rates about every 9 months, about 7% each time. We do not leave long-standing tenants at their move-in rate. In an oversupplied market, check your in-place rate against local street rates first, and slow or skip the increase for tenants already at or above street.

The turnover math

Assumptions: one 10x10 unit that rents for $100 per month (the benchmark unit; scale it to your market). We raise the stayer 7% every 9 months. Street rate rises on the same schedule, so a replacement tenant pays about what the stayer would pay. Two vacant months and a $150 turnover cost are assumptions. Use your own numbers. The model leaves out move-in discounts, which would widen the gap.

Tenant stays all 36 months:

  • Months 1-9: $100 x 9 = $900
  • Months 10-18: $107 x 9 = $963
  • Months 19-27: $114.49 x 9 = $1,030
  • Months 28-36: $122.50 x 9 = $1,103
  • Total: about $3,996 (a flat $100 for 36 months would be $3,600)

Tenant leaves after month 18:

  • Months 1-18: $900 + $963 = $1,863
  • Months 19-20: vacant, $0
  • Months 21-27: new tenant at $114.49 x 7 = $801
  • Months 28-36: $122.50 x 9 = $1,103
  • Minus about $150 for marketing, cleaning and paperwork
  • Total: about $3,617

The tenant who stays wins by about $379, roughly 9% of the stay-put total. The new tenant pays the same rent, so the gain is not a higher rate. It is avoided vacancy (2 months x $114.49 = $229) plus the $150 turn cost. The gain is per unit, over three years.

The risk on the other side

A tenant whose in-place rate sits above street rate is the move-out risk. If street rates do not keep pace with your increases, the stayer can end up paying more than a new tenant would. We check in-place rate against street rate before each increase.

Why turnover is riskier than it looks

  1. Re-renting takes longer when more units are available nearby.
  2. Street-rate growth is not guaranteed. Do not underwrite last year's increases.
  3. Turnover costs are easy to miss. Move-in work, marketing, cleanup and some unpaid rent.

Why buyers like long-term tenants

1. Predictable cash.

Tenants who stay pay on a known pattern, and a documented increase schedule shows a buyer how income grows.

2. Higher economic occupancy.

Physical occupancy counts units with a tenant. Economic occupancy is rent actually collected, divided by rent if every unit were full.

Example: a 300-unit facility (about 33,000 net rentable sf) at $0.80 per sf in a small Arizona town has full-rent potential of $316,800 a year. Collecting $285,120 is 90% economic occupancy. Osborne describes his own facility that was 100% occupied but about 85% economic, because of nonpayment and bad debts (Osborne, Investors Guide).

3. A stronger price.

Buyers look at the trailing 12 months (T12) of actual income and expenses. They also judge how safe that income is. Stable income is worth more than volatile income.

A cap rate is NOI divided by price. Flip it and price equals NOI divided by the cap rate. Buyers use cap rate as a shortcut, but they price on the income they expect to earn. Income a buyer trusts can earn a lower cap rate, so a higher price. Some buyers also see below-street rents as room to raise, so tenure helps most when the income is documented.

Example with the facility above: $156,816 NOI (net operating income: income after operating costs, before loan payments), at a 55% margin after a 6% management fee and 90% economic occupancy. Illustration only, not a quote:

  • At a 7.0% cap rate: $156,816 / 0.07 = about $2,240,000
  • At a 6.5% cap rate: $156,816 / 0.065 = about $2,413,000

The gap is about $172,000.

What to do before you sell

If you own one to three facilities and might sell within a few years:

  • Track tenant tenure. Keep a rent roll with move-in dates. Buyers will ask for it, and it shows how many tenants have stayed 24+, 12+ and 6+ months.
  • Raise on a schedule. Regular increases on existing tenants, checked against street rate, beat rare large ones and show buyers a working system.
  • Track each tenant's in-place rate against street rate.
  • Underwrite slow re-rents. Buyers may assume longer vacancy than you do.

Ready to see how your tenant history looks to a buyer?

The Gorden Group can review your tenant history, estimate what a buyer would pay, and show you where to improve before you list.

If you want to talk through your property, Connect with the Gorden Group or request a property valuation